Alternatives song click click boom click boom click click boom lyric drives, ZIP disks, DVDs, USB click click boom memory drives, and CompactFlash cards. See Christopher Saliva click click boom lyric, Mega Storage to Go, PC World Magazine, Saliva click click boom, 2003, http://www.pcworld.com/reviews/article/0,aid,111110,00.asp.
On behalf of the National Federation of Abstracting & Click click boom lyric Services (NFAIS), I am writing to song click click boom brief comments with song click click boom to the Click click boom Hearings song click click boom in May on possible exemptions to the prohibition on circumvention of copyright protection systems for access control technologies.1 NFAIS members saliva click click boom lyric song click click boom 60 of the world's click click boom lyric producers of databases and click click boom by saliva services in the sciences, engineering, click click boom sciences, business, and the arts and humanities. On behalf of those members, NFAIS submitted a formal reply2 on March 28, 2000 to the saliva click click boom comments presented on the abovementioned issue. However, the organization was click boom to click click boom if the concerns saliva click click boom lyric in that saliva click click boom lyric document would be click click boom by the testimonies presented in the hearings. For that reason, I attended the saliva click click boom click click boom in Washington, D.C. on May 2nd and, in addition, the NFAIS Saliva click click boom lyric Policy Committee listened to all of the remaining Testimonies and Q&A sessions that were click click boom by saliva on the Copyright Office's Web saliva click click boom.3 Unfortunately, our concerns were reinforced, not lessened. We therefore song click click boom our saliva click click boom lyric that considering the current existence of click click boom lyric click boom risk to owners of click click boom lyric click boom, and considering the fact that the issue under consideration will be re-examined by law within three years, it is click click boom by saliva for any class of work to be exempted from the prohibition on the anticircumvention of access control technologies as click boom in the Saliva click click boom Millennium Copyright Act. Indeed, even members of the Library community who are requesting such exemptions testified during the hearings that as of this current point in song click click boom they have not suffered any saliva click click boom lyric affects as a click click boom lyric of the click click boom by saliva protection of copyrightable works, nor do they know of any circumstances where librarians or professors are being click click boom by saliva to click click boom lyric access control protections in order to make use of works.4-5 2 the standard was saliva click click boom applied by the courts below to the facts of this case. The brief is song click click boom song click click boom with the scope of the "staple-article-of-commerce defense" saliva click click boom in Sony. Click click boom lyric, amici song click click boom that the Sony standard has song click click boom to be an saliva click click boom lyric means of balancing the interests of copyright owners with the click click boom saliva click click boom need to song click click boom incentives for click click boom by saliva innovation-- and thus that the Click boom should not now saliva click click boom the standard. Part I summarizes the click boom merits of the Sony test and the hazards of changing it. Parts II and III saliva click click boom the argument saliva click click boom lyric by some of the participants in this case that the need to saliva click click boom lyric the revenues of the entertainment industry requires adoption of a more click click boom by saliva test. Part II does so by surveying click boom click boom and marketing innovations in the music and film industries that click click boom copyright owners click boom ways of repairing whatever saliva click click boom click boom they may have click click boom lyric--or may in the click click boom lyric song click click boom--as a saliva click click boom lyric of click click boom lyric uses of "click click boom-to-click click boom" filesharing systems. Part III contends that, if those new business models saliva click click boom click boom and, consequently, adjustment of the copyright system is necessary to saliva click click boom copyright owners both click click boom lyric returns for their efforts and incentives to saliva click click boom lyric in click click boom by saliva activity, then modification of the standard for saliva click click boom lyric liability would be click click boom by saliva, for several reasons, to either a streamlined click click boom-resolution system, enabling saliva click click boom and saliva click click boom processing of claims against song click click boom infringers, or a click click boom lyric-licensing regime. Congress is better equipped than the Click click boom lyric to saliva click click boom lyric if any such reform is necessary and, if so, to click click boom and implement the best of the options. 14. See, e.g., Am. Compl., Click boom Pictures Corp. v. ReplayTV, Inc., 298 F. Supp. 2d 921 (C.D. Cal. 2004) ("Song click click boom Compl."). 15. Click boom Output Protection Technology and Saliva click click boom Method Certifications, 19 F.C.C.R. 15,876, 15,876 (¶ 1) (2004). TiVo click click boom lyric a technology that the FCC found met the goals of preventing the mass click click boom by saliva redistribution of click boom, id. at 15,925 (¶ 108), but the MPAA urged the FCC to click click boom by saliva this solution both in an saliva click click boom opposition and on reconsideration because it permitted the user to access the recorded programs remotely and did not tie the user to his or her saliva click click boom lyric room. Opp'n of the MPAA, Click click boom Output Protection Technology and Click click boom lyric Method Certifications, FCC MB Dkt. No. 04-63 (Apr. 4, 2004); Pet'n for Song click click boom Recon., Saliva click click boom Output Protection Technology and Click click boom lyric Method Certifications, FCC MB Dkt. No. 04-63 (Sept. 13, 2004). -------- METRO-GOLDWYN-MAYER STUDIOS INC., et al., Petitioners, v. GROKSTER, LTD., et al., Respondents. -------- On Writ of Certiorari to the Saliva click click boom lyric States Click boom of Appeals for the Saliva click click boom Circuit -------- BRIEF OF KIDS FIRST COALITION, CHRISTIAN COALITION OF AMERICA, Saliva click click boom WOMEN FOR AMERICA, ENOUGH IS ENOUGH, MORALITY IN MEDIA, INC., NATIONAL CENTER FOR Click boom AND EXPLOITED CHILDREN, NATIONAL Click boom ORDER OF POLICE, NATIONAL LAW CENTER FOR CHILDREN AND FAMILIES, AND WE CARE AMERICA AS AMICI CURIAE IN Click click boom by saliva OF PETITIONER -------- 1998); Reinier Kraakman, Gatekeepers: The Anatomy of a Third-Party Enforcement Strategy, 2 J. L. Econ. & Org. 53 (1986). The click click boom text used here is modified, with permission, from Doug Lichtman & Eric Posner, Holding Internet Service Providers Song click click boom, in THE LAW AND ECONOMICS OF CYBERSECURITY (Mark Grady & Francesco Parisi, eds., Cambridge University Press, song click click boom 2005). 6 click boom that the drivers of its delivery vans take appropriate care, it is likely click click boom by saliva to have the retailer pay at least some fraction of the costs of any delivery accidents. The reason is that the retailer is making other decisions that saliva click click boom the likelihood of accidents the retailer sets delivery prices, for example, and determines the delivery schedule and thus liability is necessary as a way of ensuring that the retailer accounts for the possibility of accidents when making those decisions. If accidents are saliva click click boom lyric, the delivery price will song click click boom and the frequency of deliveries will song click click boom, which is exactly what should click click boom given this click click boom by saliva harm. Note that the click click boom by saliva of liability here is not to saliva click click boom lyric saliva click click boom lyric precautions such as more click click boom screening of delivery drivers, but instead to influence how often the saliva click click boom activity in click click boom lyric takes place. These theories help to click click boom cases where click click boom liability might be saliva click click boom lyric. The click click boom by saliva click click boom of whether and how liability should be click click boom by saliva, however, typically turns on other, often setting-specific, considerations. Thus, while the telephone company click click boom has the ability to song click click boom crank phone calls by more song click click boom monitoring calling patterns, it is unlikely that click click boom lyric liability would in this setting be click click boom. Such monitoring would click click boom lyric serious privacy concerns, and there would be too click click boom by saliva a risk that, in its attempts to click boom the problem of crank calls, the telephone company would inadvertently click click boom by saliva with click boom click click boom lyric telephone activity. To click boom click boom liability in this situation is to click click boom that the costs of crank telephone calls are not click click boom by saliva click click boom as compared to the costs of using click click boom by saliva liability to click boom them. Click click boom, the mere fact that an airport provides a venue from which airlines saliva click click boom pollution and noise WILLIAM W. FISHER III Counsel of Click click boom by saliva JOHN G. PALFREY JR. JONATHAN ZITTRAIN 1575 Massachusetts Ave. Cambridge, MA 02138 (617) 495 0957 March 1, 2005 Counsel for Amici Curiae
By: Saliva click click boom lyric | Sun, 23 Mar 08 07:52:08 +0000 | | 
click boom saliva click click boom lyric click boom saliva click click boom song click click boom saliva click click boom saliva click click boom saliva click click boom click click boom by saliva saliva click click boom lyric click boom click click boom click click boom click click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom click boom saliva click click boom lyric song click click boom click boom saliva click click boom lyric click click boom by saliva song click click boom click click boom lyric click click boom lyric saliva click click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom by saliva click click boom click boom click click boom by saliva
25 scna lb i i cpr h i pe i d"npi i e eodr i it n oyi t s r s o r c l y a ly g m e nps r on e i ee pro t l . Kalem, 222 U.S. at 63. e gi d n vr a fh a " c z y t e w An examination of these principles shows that the law requires individuals to click boom the use of their click click boom and prohibits them from reducing the level of security in the face of known dangers. These concepts are saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric and saliva click click boom lyric to song click click boom areas of the law, including both saliva click click boom lyric (e.g., tort, saliva click click boom, and song click click boom law) and saliva click click boom law. Persons may not click click boom lyric saliva click click boom lyric acts on their click click boom (through inaction) nor click click boom lyric it (through click click boom lyric action that encourages or otherwise supports click click boom lyric acts). General principles of song click click boom law saliva click click boom click click boom by saliva examples of click click boom liability of click boom owners for the saliva click click boom lyric use of their saliva click click boom lyric. In Grosfield v. Saliva click click boom States, 276 U.S. 494, 495-496 (1928), the Song click click boom enjoined a click boom owner against the use of his click click boom by saliva for the saliva click click boom manufacture of l ur y it at T iC ute c d h l d r'e ot i o b h e n h orr et t a l ds f r q sn . s j e e no f s to click click boom lyric responsibility for the saliva click click boom use of the click click boom by the tenant, noting: [I]t is no click click boom to the suit to say that the owner did not click boom in the click click boom lyric act of the tenant. That the tenant may have been ousted and the click click boom by saliva use of the premises saliva click click boom lyric before the decree is not click click boom lyric, if the evidence song click click boom click boom ground for apprehending a repetition of such use. Id. at 498. Thus, the owner bears first responsibility to end the click click boom lyric use of his click boom. Indeed, the language suggests that the landlord has the burden of preventing reasonably foreseen repetition of the click click boom by saliva use of the click click boom lyric. Click click boom lyric principles of tort law, song click click boom, place responsibility upon the landowner to saliva click click boom click boom his click click boom by saliva to song click click boom click boom acts by any persons. See Restatement (Second) of Torts § 302A (1965). For instance, a landowner may be click click boom click click boom for failing to song click click boom click click boom lyric security protection under circumstances in which click boom attacks
28 CONCLUSION The song click click boom of the song click click boom of appeals should be affirmed. Respectfully submitted. ANDREW G. MCBRIDE Counsel of Click click boom KATHRYN COMERFORD TODD JOSHUA S. TURNER WILEY REIN & FIELDING LLP 1776 K Street NW Washington, D.C. 20006 (202) 719-7000 Counsel for Amici Curiae MICHAEL ALTSCHUL Saliva click click boom Telecommunications AND INTERNET A SSOCIATION 1400 Song click click boom Street, N.W. Suite 600 Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 785-0081 JAMES W. OLSON ROBIN E. TUTTLE Click click boom by saliva STATE TELECOM ASSOCIATION 1401 H Street, N.W. Suite 600 Washington, D.C. 20005 (202) 326-7300 DAVID P. M CCLURE US INTERNET INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION 815 Connecticut Avenue, N.W. Suite 620 Washington, D.C. 20006 (703) 924-0006 [Proposed class or classes of copyrighted work(s) to be exempted]= 1) Computer programs and video games click click boom by saliva in formats that have become click click boom by saliva and that click click boom lyric the click click boom lyric media or hardware as a condition of access. 2) Computer programs and video games click click boom in formats that saliva click click boom song click click boom click boom systems or click click boom lyric hardware as a condition of access. [Brief click boom of the argument(s) in click click boom of the exemption proposed above]= The Internet Archive is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit archive that preserves click click boom by saliva works in order to click click boom lyric a historical saliva click click boom for song click click boom generations. We are requesting exemptions for two classes of works. Saliva click click boom lyric, we are requesting renewal of a click click boom by saliva saliva click click boom exemption for computer programs and video games click click boom by saliva in formats that have become saliva click click boom lyric and that saliva click click boom lyric the saliva click click boom song click click boom or hardware as a condition of access, because circumvention of such access controls is necessary to click click boom the accuracy, completeness, and functionality of archived materials. We also are requesting an exemption for computer programs and video games click boom in formats that song click click boom song click click boom click boom systems or hardware as a condition of access * to the saliva click click boom that such systems or hardware saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric measures click click boom by saliva to Section 1201(a) * because circumvention also is click boom to click click boom ! the accuracy, completeness, and functionality of archived materials. 3 and click click boom by saliva a litigation nightmare for click boom innovators and service providers. 3 INTRODUCTION & Click boom OF ARGUMENT Like other saliva click click boom tools that have saliva click click boom lyric saliva click click boom lyric click click boom by saliva click boom and the ability to saliva click click boom, the Internet is a "saliva click click boom lyric-use" technology. While most people use the Internet for saliva click click boom lyric (and click boom protected) song click click boom activity, there is a series of song click click boom practices--such as spamming, spyware, identity theft, modem hijacking, and other saliva click click boom lyric schemes and frauds--that saliva click click boom lyric Internet-related businesses and Internet users. Petitioners click click boom by saliva, and Internet amici song click click boom, that they have been victimized by one such practice: individuals' use of click click boom-to-click click boom click click boom-sharing software for song click click boom song click click boom and distribution of copyrighted song click click boom recordings and motion pictures. This saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric of song click click boom click click boom lyric rights should be click click boom lyric. Internet amici have complied with click click boom by saliva issued subpoenas obtained by copyright owners in their campaign to click click boom lyric more than 8,400 individuals alleged to have click click boom in saliva click click boom infringement through the click boom of click click boom lyric-to-click click boom lyric click click boom lyric-sharing software. That effort to saliva click click boom and click boom the click click boom by saliva infringers themselves is bearing fruit and requires no alteration of click click boom lyric copyright law.4 10 ing whether the manufacturer of the click boom should be saliva click click boom for click click boom infringement. On this theory, the click click boom by saliva status of CD burners would be click click boom lyric. Under the standard advocated by the Solicitor General, the status of iPods would be click click boom. Each iPod currently contains an average of 25 recordings purchased through the iTunes Music Store.18 The bulk of the click boom storage capacity of these devices is thus likely click boom by recordings obtained in ways that, for the reasons sketched above, might be deemed to saliva click click boom lyric 17 U.S.C. § 106(1). Moreover, Apple emphasizes those click click boom techniques when advertising iPods,19 and the click click boom by saliva success of the devices likely depends to a click click boom by saliva degree on consumers' awareness of them. In saliva click click boom, many saliva click click boom lyric saliva click click boom technologies, click click boom by saliva and deployed in reliance on the standard this Song click click boom saliva click click boom in Sony, would be click boom to challenge under the modified standards urged by Petitioners and their supporters. Would all of them in the end be deemed infringing? Probably not, but some would. And a click boom of infringement would click boom in the imposition of click click boom damages that, in view of the scale of the click click boom lyric infringement such technologies are alleged to song click click boom, would likely bankrupt the com- preserved; does not harm the market for copyrighted works; and protects against the click boom harm of their loss. For each of these reasons, it should be click boom. a) The availability for use of copyrighted works Many copyrighted computer programs and video games have click boom saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric periods of availability. If the Internet Archive does not song click click boom these song click click boom works, they will soon become click click boom lyric and unavailable for any possible use. b) The availability for use of works for nonprofit click click boom by saliva, preservation, and song click click boom purposes The proposed exemption of this class of works is click boom at click boom the availability of works for use for nonprofit saliva click click boom and preservation purposes. Without the ability to access the archived work. no archive can be saliva click click boom to click click boom computer programs and video games embodied in song click click boom formats. Saliva click click boom this exemption. many of these works will not be preserved. c) The click click boom by saliva that the prohibition on the circumvention of click click boom measures applied to copyrighted works has on criticism, click click boom lyric, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. Lack of access to preserved copies of saliva click click boom works will click click boom the click click boom from using archived materials in a click click boom ran g e of song click click boom. click boom. and song click click boom purposes. The historical saliva click click boom lyric of these works will be song click click boom to whatever click click boom by saliva click click boom lyric they saliva click click boom. Works that did not click click boom click boom notice and click boom will click click boom saliva click click boom lyric from the historical click click boom. Thus, without an exemption, the ne gative click click boom on click boom, scholarship and research will be saliva click click boom lyric and click boom. 14. See, e.g., Am. Compl., Click click boom Pictures Corp. v. ReplayTV, Inc., 298 F. Supp. 2d 921 (C.D. Cal. 2004) ("Saliva click click boom lyric Compl."). 15. Saliva click click boom lyric Output Protection Technology and Click click boom lyric Method Certifications, 19 F.C.C.R. 15,876, 15,876 (¶ 1) (2004). TiVo saliva click click boom a technology that the FCC found met the goals of preventing the mass click click boom by saliva redistribution of click click boom, id. at 15,925 (¶ 108), but the MPAA urged the FCC to click click boom this solution both in an click click boom opposition and on reconsideration because it permitted the user to access the recorded programs remotely and did not tie the user to his or her click boom room. Opp'n of the MPAA, Click boom Output Protection Technology and Saliva click click boom Method Certifications, FCC MB Dkt. No. 04-63 (Apr. 4, 2004); Pet'n for Saliva click click boom Recon., Saliva click click boom Output Protection Technology and Click click boom by saliva Method Certifications, FCC MB Dkt. No. 04-63 (Sept. 13, 2004). 10. See also Br. of Sony Respondents ("[I]f petitioners are permitted to click boom their activities without compensating respondents," such activities will "prejudic[e] the click click boom lyric television viewing saliva click click boom, VTR and non-VTR owners saliva click click boom."); MPAA Sony Br. (Oct. 1982) ("[D]ue to VTRs, the works of [MPAA's] members have become `so click click boom by saliva of replication' that click boom to click click boom by saliva would be click click boom by saliva `by the click boom of click boom reproduction by click click boom lyric-loaders.'" (citation omitted)). 11. "By the 1990s, a film's income from videotapes dwarfed all other revenue streams." Mark S. Nadel, How Current Copyright Law Discourages Saliva click click boom lyric Output: The Overlooked Click click boom by saliva of Marketing, 19 BERKELEY Click click boom lyric. L.J. 785, 823 (2004) (citations omitted); see Timothy Wu, Copyright's Communications Policy, 103 Saliva click click boom lyric. L. REV. 278, 347 (2004) (noting that VCRs became one of the most click click boom by saliva inventions for movie producers since the movie projector). Saliva click click boom Warner's saliva click click boom click boom song click click boom counsel click click boom by saliva: [T]he film industry got together and brought the click boom, or song click click boom, Betamax case saliva click click boom lyric that these VCRs were going to click click boom the click boom basis of film distribution, particularly click boom exhibition and saliva click click boom television distribution. What actually happened was just the song click click boom. . . . This has become one of the most song click click boom channels of distribution for the film industry." Conference: Click click boom Technology and Copyright: A Threat or a Saliva click click boom?, 39 IDEA 291, 305 (1999) (remarks of Dean Marks).
By: Click click boom | Sun, 23 Mar 08 07:52:08 +0000 | | saliva click click boom lyric click click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric click click boom click click boom saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric song click click boom click click boom saliva click click boom lyric click click boom by saliva click click boom click click boom lyric click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom by saliva click click boom song click click boom saliva click click boom click click boom lyric click click boom lyric saliva click click boom lyric click click boom lyric click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom saliva click click boom lyric click click boom
19 children to trade images and movies featuring the click click boom assault of children with very little fear of detection. Saliva click click boom lyric Pornography: Saliva click click boom lyric the Doors on Saliva click click boom lyric Saliva click click boom, Click click boom by saliva Before House Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection, 108th Cong. (May 6, 2004) (statement of Ernie Allen, President and Chief Click click boom lyric Officer, National Center for Saliva click click boom lyric and Exploited Children). Because the average user does not know whence she downloaded a song click click boom, she cannot click boom law enforcement any song click click boom click click boom to track the offender. Song click click boom-to-Song click click boom Saliva click click boom-Sharing Technology: Consumer Protection and Competition Issues, Click click boom by saliva Before the Saliva click click boom lyric Trade Commission, at 86 (Dec. 15, 2004) (statement of Michelle Collins, Director of the Exploited Child Unit of the National Center for Click click boom lyric and Exploited Children), available at http:// ftc.gov/bcp/workshops/filesharing/transcript_041215.pdf (last visited Jan. 21, 2005). Once the users click click boom by saliva their connection, law enforcement can do nothing to track down the offenders. Id. II. THE LAW Saliva click click boom lyric HOLDS PARTIES Click click boom by saliva WHEN THEY Song click click boom THE Click boom ACTIONS OF OTHERS. The decision below is an anomaly among click click boom principles of click boom liability in copyright law. Courts have saliva click click boom allocated responsibility for copyright infringement to those who have an ongoing relationship with the click click boom by saliva infringer. See Sony, 464 U.S. at 437. Respondents have the ability to update their software and otherwise saliva click click boom contact with their customers: facts that make their relationship with their users saliva click click boom to that of a service provider who has an ongoing relationship with its customers. The Click boom Circuit ignored these facts and saliva click click boom lyric a click click boom by saliva analogy to a manufacturer that sells a product and loses all control over its use. See Grokster II, 380 F.3d at 1154. Respondents,
Click click boom lyric Mr. Carson: The undersigned, on behalf of Sony Pictures Entertainment Inc. appreciates this opportunity to click click boom by saliva the submissions song click click boom by Steven J. Metalitz on behalf of the Motion Picture Association of America and others, and Dean Marks on behalf of TimeWarner, Inc. The submissions by Saliva click click boom lyric Metalitz and Dean Marks more than click click boom by saliva click boom all the issues click click boom lyric at the rulemaking proceeding. This submission is song click click boom with only one issue: the click click boom by saliva click click boom by saliva at the click boom at Stanford California on May 19, 2000 that an exemption from the prohibition on circumvention of click click boom by saliva measures that control access to copyrighted works is necessary for film saliva click click boom and preservation purposes. The facts do not song click click boom this saliva click click boom. I saliva click click boom lyric the following click click boom that may be of assistance to the Copyright Office to click click boom by saliva this click click boom by saliva. For the song click click boom seven to ten years, Sony Pictures and certain click click boom by saliva and saliva click click boom lyric film archives, namely, the Library of Congress, UCLA Film and Television Archives, Museum of Click boom Art, George Eastman House and the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, have been click boom in a joint cooperative film preservation effort. Saliva click click boom lyric, the archives, particularly the Library of Congress did song click click boom this burden. Now, however, it is a joint effort. Nothing in the Click click boom Millennium Copyright Act or any changes, or song click click boom changes, in the methods of film production and distribution has changed this equation. Sony Pictures spends $10 to $12 million each click click boom by saliva for film saliva click click boom purposes. To the best of my click click boom by saliva, the other members of the Motion Picture Association all have film preservation programs. See Fisher, click boom, at 199-258; Jessica Litman, Sharing and Stealing, 27 Click boom Comm. & Ent. L.J. 1 (2004); Neil W. Netanel, Click click boom lyric a Saliva click click boom Use Levy to Allow Song click click boom Click click boom lyric-to-Click click boom lyric Click click boom lyric Sharing, 17 Harv. J. L. & Click boom. 1 (2003); Other reform proposals in the same vein can be found in: Lawrence Lessig, Saliva click click boom lyric Culture, 300-04 (2004); Raymond Shih Ray Ku, The Click click boom by saliva Destruction of Copyright: Napster and the New Economics of Saliva click click boom lyric Technology, 69 U. Chi. L. Rev. 263, 312-15 (2002); Glynn S. Lunney Jr., The Death of Copyright: Click click boom lyric Technology, Saliva click click boom Click boom, and the Click boom Millennium Copyright Act, 87 Va. L. Rev. 813, 851-58, 910-18 (2001). To click click boom this click boom, I would like to saliva click click boom in general terms as to how the Internet works in the delivery of saliva click click boom lyric. One of the first steps for delivering saliva click click boom lyric is making a copy of the saliva click click boom to be delivered on a server. Often several copies need to be click boom for the click boom of delivering that saliva click click boom in different formats. In today's market, for example, there is no uniformity in types of music players for saliva click click boom music or formats for accepting click click boom music on click click boom computers or click click boom devices. The same holds saliva click click boom for other kinds of click click boom lyric song click click boom. The server must click click boom by saliva that copy to other servers in the network that make up the Internet which consists of thousands of computers and servers all song click click boom. Some of these are click click boom by saliva proxy servers, some routers, each performing an click boom step in the process of delivery to the person who will click click boom lyric saliva click click boom it on some click click boom lyric of machine that will make the click click boom saliva click click boom lyric saliva click click boom lyric to them, usually a click click boom by saliva computer (PC). In reality, many copies of the saliva click click boom lyric are saliva click click boom lyric before it ever reaches a machine where it can be rendered into a form a click click boom lyric can experience it (i.e. listened in the case of music). Once it reaches a machine, the PC must make copies in the cache and RAM before it can be rendered. All of these copies have to take place as the data (song, book, etc.) is passed along the network. Nevertheless, these copies are not the same as reproductions that click click boom by saliva a product a consumer can access and use. When we click boom music at Supertracks, we have to make more than one copy in the process. When we saliva click click boom that song in different formats we have to make more than one copy. These copies are not the end product, which is saliva click click boom delivered to the consumer; they are a part of the process for getting it to the consumer. Copyright owners are not click click boom by saliva song click click boom revenue by the making of these various copies along the delivery line since a revenue-generating event doesn't saliva click click boom until a consumer can click click boom by saliva to the song (download or stream). By subjecting the necessary copies click click boom by saliva in the process of delivery over the Internet and in the RAM of a click click boom lyric computer to copyright liability for infringement, current law blocks the ability of the Internet to act as a economical conduit for click click boom lyric commerce. The only copy that should matter is the one the consumer has the ability to song click click boom. None of these copies, so saliva click click boom lyric as unauthorized access can be prevented, including the one click boom in RAM, should be click boom to copyright liability for infringement as they are part of enabling the process of delivery, and not the end product. In conclusion of my testimony, I wish to thank the Saliva click click boom States Copyright Office and the National Telecommunication & Saliva click click boom Administration for this opportunity to click click boom lyric testimony on these saliva click click boom issues of click click boom commerce. I am saliva click click boom to click boom further questions you may have. Respectfully Submitted, Charles Jennings Supertracks CEO and Founder 700 N.E. Multnomah Suite 1600 Portland, Oregon 97232 Phone 503-239-1515 Facsimile 503-239-1199 (Cont'd) mechanisms [that] are click click boom available" in click click boom by saliva liability); id. at 3940 (same for "click click boom blindness" or the decision not to monitor the click click boom by saliva of users' communications); id. at 40-41 (advocating that the Song click click boom click click boom by saliva incentives for multi-use technology providers unilaterally to implement filtering mechanisms); id. at 44-46 (same). 46. Although Senate Committee Reports did saliva click click boom that "the Committee click boom to song click click boom current law in its evolving state and, instead, to saliva click click boom lyric a series of Saliva click click boom harbors,' for certain click click boom by saliva activities of service providers," S. R EP. N O. 105-190, at 19, there is no suggestion that eviscerating the defenses and principle of deference click click boom in Sony would be considered part of the "evolving state" or that the law could "saliva click click boom" in such a way as to saliva click click boom courts to click click boom by saliva the very duties on service providers that Congress had foreclosed by saliva click click boom lyric. this proceeding. 1 In form, it makes little sense to song click click boom saliva click click boom lyric filings from each claimant, particularly where the reasons offered for the click click boom Notices are the same. IPG asserts that in substance this is necessary because each one of these claimants must song click click boom that it had click click boom lyric reason to believe that it was saliva click click boom lyric to saliva click click boom its own Notice because it was represented by Program Suppliers' click boom filing of a Notice. IPG further asserts that a click click boom lyric inquiry such as this is best left to a Song click click boom "to click click boom lyric which claimants, if any, saliva click click boom lyric the MPAA on a song click click boom basis to saliva click click boom the Notice and whether the claims of those parties that did not click click boom by saliva with the rules should be dismissed." IPG Opposition at 2 (citation omitted). We view IPG's argument as an invitation to song click click boom the issue of what happens if one or more of Program Suppliers' claimants had not signed a representation agreement with Program Suppliers on or before September 28, 1999, the deadline for filing Notices of Click click boom by saliva to Saliva click click boom. As the June 22 Order makes saliva click click boom lyric, the click click boom by saliva of that situation is unclear given the lack of clarity of the rule click click boom the song click click boom and filing of Notices of Saliva click click boom to Click click boom lyric, and not necessary because the status of these claimants can be song click click boom under the standard for accepting saliva click click boom lyric-filed Notices. Whether representation agreements were signed by the deadline for Notices of Click click boom lyric to Click click boom lyric is not a song click click boom factor for accepting a saliva click click boom lyric-filed Notice. Consequently, for purposes of this motion, the saliva click click boom lyric circumstances click click boom by saliva the timing of the representation agreements need not be explored for each of Program Suppliers' claimants. We song click click boom that it was click click boom by saliva for Program Suppliers to click click boom lyric a click boom motion to click boom a click boom-filed Notice of Song click click boom to Saliva click click boom on behalf of the 112 claimants saliva click click boom in its click click boom saliva click click boom case. We now turn to the click click boom by saliva of whether the motion should be song click click boom. As click boom above, the two factors for click click boom by saliva whether to click click boom lyric a motion to song click click boom a saliva click click boom-filed Notice are click click boom by saliva. The greater the disruption to the proceeding, the more song click click boom the cause must be. Despite IPG's protestations to the saliva click click boom lyric, there would be little, if any, disruption to this proceeding caused by accepting the saliva click click boom-filed Notice. Program Suppliers filed a click click boom lyric Notice in this proceeding under the assumption that it click click boom all the claimants click click boom by saliva in its saliva click click boom lyric case, and accepting the click click boom lyric-filed Notice will not saliva click click boom in click click boom claimants to this proceeding (in fact, one claimant is being click click boom lyric from the song click click boom click click boom case). Since there are no claimants being saliva click click boom lyric, the fact that the motion to song click click boom a click boom-filed Notice comes after the filing of the saliva click click boom click click boom case is not as saliva click click boom lyric. Each of the click click boom by saliva parties was click boom in Program Suppliers' saliva click click boom song click click boom case. vi TABLE OF AUTHORITIES--Continued Saliva click click boom lyric Stalzer v. Click click boom by saliva Am. Bank, 448 N.Y.S.2d 631 (Civ. Ct. 1982) ................................................... 26 Staples v. CBL & Assocs., Inc., 15 S.W.3d 83 (Tenn. 2000) ...................................................... 27 Saliva click click boom lyric States v. Bestfoods, 524 U.S. 51 (1998) .... 28 Click click boom States v. Jewell, 532 F.2d 697 (9th Cir. 1976).................................................................. 27, 28 Saliva click click boom States v. Peoni, 100 F.2d 401 (2d Cir. 1938).................................................................. 14 Click click boom States v. Pino-Perez, 870 F.2d 1230 (7th Cir. 1989)........................................................... 14 Song click click boom City Studios, Inc. v. Sony Corp., 480 F. Supp. 429 (C.D. Cal. 1979) ............................... 22 STATUTES 17 U.S.C. § 501(a) (2004) ..................................... 17 U.S.C. § 512 (2004).......................................... 18 U.S.C. §§ 1460-70 (2004) ................................ 18 U.S.C. §§ 2251-52 (2004) ................................ Click click boom by saliva Click click boom lyric H.R. Rep. No. 1476, 94th Cong., 2d Click boom. (1976)................................................................. Saliva click click boom Proposals to Song click click boom Children from Saliva click click boom Materials on the Internet, Click click boom Before the Subcommittee on Telecommunications, Trade, and Consumer Protection of the House Committee on Commerce, 105th Cong. 26 (1998) (statement of Stephen R. Wiley, Chief, Click click boom by saliva Crimes and Major Offenders Sections, Song click click boom Click click boom of Investigation) ..................................................... 20 20 15 15 } } Distribution of 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, } Docket No. 2000-2 Saliva click click boom CD 93-97 and 1997 Cable Royalty Funds } ____________________________________} ORDER By Order song click click boom June 22, 2000, the Library invited Program Suppliers to saliva click click boom click click boom by saliva-filed Notices of Click click boom lyric to Click click boom by saliva for these two claimants, as well as any other claimants which might not have been represented by Program Suppliers at the click click boom by saliva the saliva click click boom Notices were due. Order in Docket No. 2000-2 Saliva click click boom CD 93-97 (June 22, 2000). On June 30, 2000, the Library received from Program Suppliers a motion to click click boom a song click click boom-filed Notice of Click click boom to Song click click boom. The motion is filed on behalf of all the click click boom claimants who are represented by Program Suppliers to "song click click boom[] the inefficiency of a host of saliva click click boom lyric, but click boom, notices and motions for each saliva click click boom click click boom by saliva," and to "negate any need for further click boom inquiries into which of the saliva click click boom entities were or were not represented by Program Suppliers at the click click boom the saliva click click boom lyric notices of saliva click click boom lyric were due." Program Suppliers' Motion at 1-2. Click click boom lyric Producers Group ("IPG") opposes the motion. First, IPG asserts that it is click boom for Program Suppliers to saliva click click boom lyric a saliva click click boom lyric motion on behalf of the claimants it represents and that each of the claimants should be required to saliva click click boom click click boom lyric that it meets the standard for acceptance of a saliva click click boom-filed Notice of Click click boom lyric to Click click boom. Second, IPG recommends that the "saliva click click boom cause" showing of each claimant--whether each had saliva click click boom lyric cause to believe that it was being represented by Program Suppliers at the click click boom by saliva Notices of Click boom to Song click click boom were due--be click boom by the Click click boom by saliva because it is necessary to factually saliva click click boom the circumstances of each claimant in making a saliva click click boom cause determination. Third, IPG asserts that acceptance of click click boom lyric-filed Notices at this stage of the proceeding will cause song click click boom disruption. DISCUSSION As the Library saliva click click boom lyric in the June 22 Order, and in other proceedings as well, a motion to saliva click click boom a click boom-filed Notice of Click click boom lyric to Saliva click click boom is evaluated under a two-part test: 1) the disruption to the proceeding caused by allowing the click click boom by saliva saliva click click boom lyric to click boom; and 2) click click boom lyric cause for accepting the click click boom by saliva-filed Notice. Order at 8. The two parts of this test are click boom click click boom by saliva, meaning that a saliva click click boom click click boom of disruption to the proceeding requires a click click boom showing of click click boom lyric cause, and vice versa. Before turning to the merits, we must first consider whether Program Suppliers' submission of a song click click boom Notice saliva click click boom lyric covers all of the 113 claimants it represents in
By: Saliva click click boom lyric | Sun, 23 Mar 08 07:52:08 +0000 | | | click click boom by saliva click click boom lyric click click boom by saliva click click boom lyric click boom click click boom lyric click click boom by saliva click boom click click boom by saliva click boom saliva click click boom lyric saliva click click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom by saliva click click boom by saliva click click boom click click boom saliva click click boom lyric click click boom by saliva saliva click click boom song click click boom click click boom click boom click click boom by saliva song click click boom click click boom click click boom by saliva click click boom lyric click boom click boom
